Is the Insurance Company Spying on You in Buffalo?  

The Shocking Truth They Don’t Want You to Know About Your Personal Injury Case 

After an accident, you're already dealing with enough—pain, stress, endless medical bills. The last thing you need is some insurance company playing dirty tricks, trying to catch you off guard. 

But in New York, that’s exactly what might be happening. Big insurance companies hire private investigators to spy on claimants, hoping to find even the smallest excuse to deny your claim. It’s sneaky. It’s unfair. And it happens more than you’d think. 

The personal injury attorneys at Horn Wright, LLP, have seen this before, and we’re not letting it go without a fight. You're just trying to recover, not fend off a corporate giant looking to undermine you.  

Caught on Camera! The Shocking Ways Insurance Companies in Buffalo Track Your Every Move 

Picture this: you’re picking up a prescription, grabbing groceries, or just stepping outside to get some fresh air. You don’t realize it, but someone’s watching. A private investigator, hired by the insurance company, is sitting in a car down the street with a camera zoomed in on you. Sounds like something out of a movie, right? It’s not. It’s real life in Buffalo. 

Why You Could Be a Target Without Even Knowing It 

You don’t have to fake an injury to end up on an investigator’s radar. If you've filed a claim—especially one involving a serious injury—you could be under surveillance.  

Insurance companies don’t just go after fraudsters; they look for any reason to pay you less. That means twisting harmless moments into “proof” that you’re not really injured. 

The Shady Tactics Investigators Use to Follow You 

Private investigators don’t play fair. Here’s how they try to catch you off guard: 

• Surveillance: They’ll follow you, sometimes for days, filming you as you run errands, go to doctor’s appointments, or even just walk to your mailbox. Some even use drones for a bird’s-eye view of your daily life. 
• Social Media Stalking: Think your private Facebook or Instagram is safe? Think again. Insurers monitor social media, looking for anything they can twist against you. Even a simple check-in at a restaurant could be used to argue you’re more active than you claim. 
• Fake Interviews: Investigators might chat up your neighbors, coworkers, or even local store clerks, pretending they’re someone else. They’re fishing for any detail that could hurt your case. 

In New York, as long as they don’t trespass, most of these tactics are legal. That means they can spy from public spaces or even record from a distance while you’re at home. 

Our trusted Buffalo law firm is here to fight back and protect your rights, making sure you get every dollar you deserve. Let us handle the legal battle so you can move forward with peace of mind. 

One Clip Can Destroy Your Case! How Video Footage Wrecks Injury Claims—Even When You’re Telling the Truth 

You’re being honest about your pain. But one short, out-of-context clip could flip your case upside down.  

Insurance companies often use surveillance evidence in personal injury cases, but claimants have rights under the New York CPLR, which governs discovery and disclosure of evidence.  

Let’s say an investigator catches you bending down to tie your shoe or carrying a light grocery bag. They won’t mention that you were in agony afterward. Instead, they’ll present it as proof that you’re exaggerating your injuries. 

Insurance Lawyers Know How to Twist Surveillance – Here’s How to Fight Back 

Insurance companies have teams of lawyers trained to take small moments and spin them into big problems for your case. You’ve got to stay one step ahead: 

• Be Consistent: Stick to your doctor’s recommendations and don’t downplay your pain. Even small contradictions can hurt you. 
• Lock Down Your Social Media: Even an innocent selfie can be used against you. A woman in Canada lost her benefits because of a smiling Facebook photo. Don’t give insurers anything to twist. 
• Keep Records: Jot down details about your pain, mobility issues, and doctor visits. A personal injury journal can help counter misleading surveillance footage. 

The Most Common Ways Footage is Used Against Claimants 

Big insurance companies don’t just watch—they use what they find. Here’s how: 

• Discrediting Your Testimony: If they catch you doing something you previously said you couldn’t, they’ll claim you lied—even if it was just a one-time effort. However, under New York Insurance Law Section 2601, insurers are prohibited from engaging in unfair claims practices, including misrepresenting surveillance footage to deny valid claims. They often use grainy, context-lacking videos to cast doubt on your credibility. 
• Blaming an Old Injury: Insurers love to dig through medical records and surveillance to argue that your pain is from a pre-existing condition. They may even consult doctors who never examined you to challenge your medical claims. 
• Claiming Non-Compliance: If they see you skipping therapy sessions or moving in ways your doctor advised against, they’ll argue you’re not taking recovery seriously. Even if you missed therapy due to financial hardship or lack of transportation, insurers might try to use it against you. 

Don’t Let Big Insurance Take Advantage of You 

It’s frustrating. It’s invasive. But you’re not powerless. The right legal team can shut down these shady tactics and make sure you get the settlement you deserve.  

Our team of Buffalo personal injury lawyers At Horn Wright, LLP, know their tricks—and we know how to fight back. Whether you need an accident compensation lawyer, injury claims representation, or a New York accident attorney, one of the best law firms in America is ready to offer support.  

Contact our Buffalo law office today for your free consultation and let’s get started on protecting your case.